Issue 172: The Tension of Roots - Depth Before Display

Every great bottle begins with a negotiation. The grain pushes its starchy sweetness forward; the barrel pushes back with tannin and char. The agave insists on its mineral terroir; the still reshapes it into something new. The most compelling drinks live in this tension — not resolution, but a deliberate balance where the raw material's voice is never fully silenced.

Today's eight selections showcase producers who let their ingredients argue their case. From a wheated bourbon that foregrounds grain over wood, to an Etna white wine where volcanic soil speaks louder than winemaking, each bottle rewards the drinker who listens for the root note beneath the finish.

This issue's aroma theme centers on the raw materials asserting themselves — grain sweetness in bourbon, malt in Scotch and Irish, cooked agave in tequila, sugarcane in clairin, and fruit-forward varietal character in the wines. Train your nose to find the ingredient beneath the process.

Don’t see your special bottle? Request a review at reviews.schoolofwineandspirits.com/request-review — we’ll get to it. See every bottle we’ve reviewed to date at reviews.schoolofwineandspirits.com.

Bourbon Smooth Ambler Contradiction Bourbon Whiskey

Nestled in the Greenbrier Valley of West Virginia, Smooth Ambler Spirits blends their own pot-still bourbon with older sourced stocks to create a whiskey that embraces the contradiction between maker and merchant.

Cocktail — Valley Old Fashioned — 2 oz Smooth Ambler Contradiction · 0.25 oz demerara syrup · 3 dashes Angostura bitters · Stir over ice, strain into rocks glass with a large cube, express orange peel.

Pair with: Warm skillet cornbread served with whipped honey butter and a drizzle of sorghum syrup — the corn-on-corn echo amplifies the bourbon's grain-forward character.

Scotch Whisky Deanston 20 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky

Housed in a converted cotton mill on the banks of the River Teith in Perthshire, Deanston Distillery uses open-top mash tuns and draws its water from the river itself, producing unpeated spirit that foregrounds barley above all else.

Pair with: A tart layered with dark chocolate ganache and dried figs on a shortbread crust, finished with flaky Maldon salt — the cocoa and fruit in the whisky find perfect mirrors in the dessert.

Irish Whiskey Dingle Single Malt Cask Strength Batch No. 6 Irish Whiskey

Perched on the wild Dingle Peninsula in County Kerry, Dingle Distillery was one of Ireland's first craft whiskey producers, triple-distilling their spirit in small copper pot stills before aging in a mix of bourbon and sherry casks.

Pair with: Pan-seared duck breast with a tart cherry compote, roasted root vegetables, and a drizzle of aged balsamic — the richness of the duck meets the whiskey's cask strength intensity head-on.

Tequila Suerte Añejo Tequila

Suerte — Spanish for 'luck' — was born from an unlikely partnership between a Texas entrepreneur and a master distiller in the highlands of Arandas. But there is nothing lucky about the process: Suerte uses a traditional tahona stone to crush their slow-roasted agave, a labor-intensive method that most modern distilleries abandoned decades ago. The tahona extracts a different character from the piña — more fiber contact, more mineral depth, more of the raw personality of the plant itself. Their añejo spends a full two years in American white oak, but rather than chasing the barrel-bomb trend, the goal is integration. The agave and the wood meet as equals. In an era when tequila marketing often prioritizes celebrity endorsement and crystal bottles, Suerte quietly builds its reputation on what's inside the glass. The tension of roots, indeed: a spirit that draws its power from the ground up.

Cocktail — The Root Line — [object Object]

Pair with: The smoky, earthy complexity of a traditional Oaxacan mole negro — with its 30-plus ingredients layered into a dark, bittersweet sauce — mirrors the quiet depth of Suerte Añejo. The tequila's roasted agave and dark chocolate notes interlock with the mole's charred chiles and Mexican chocolate, while its pepper spice cuts through the richness of the braised chicken thigh. Together, they create a pairing where neither element dominates — both simply go deeper.

Awards: Double Gold — San Francisco World Spirits Competition, Gold Medal — Spirits of Mexico Competition, 94 Points — Tasting Panel Magazine

Gin Spring44 Mountain Gin

At 9,000 feet in the Colorado Rockies, Spring44's namesake spring produces water of extraordinary purity and mineral composition. Founders Jeff McPhie and Tom Segelke didn't choose this water for marketing — they chose it because they believed the foundation of any great spirit is what you can't see. Their Mountain Gin reflects this conviction: a botanical bill heavy on roots (angelica, orris) and classical juniper, distilled through a process that privileges the unseen architecture of flavor over surface-level botanical showmanship. The result is a gin that tastes like its terroir — mountain bedrock filtered through centuries of granite, expressed as something simultaneously clean and profoundly deep.

Cocktail — The Root Cellar Martini — [object Object]

Pair with: Sunchokes roasted until caramelized and nutty, tossed with toasted hazelnuts, shaved Parmigiano, and a light lemon-thyme vinaigrette. The earthy sweetness of the sunchokes mirrors the gin's angelica and orris root character, while the hazelnuts echo its woody juniper backbone. The lemon vinaigrette lifts everything without competing with the spirit's mineral restraint.

Awards: Double Gold — San Francisco World Spirits Competition 2020, Gold — Denver International Spirits Competition 2021, Best in Class Gin — American Craft Spirits Association 2019

Rum Centenario Real Rum

Costa Rica is rarely the first country mentioned in rum conversations, and Centenario Internacional has never seemed to mind. Operating since 1985 in San José, the distillery uses a solera system — a fractional blending method more commonly associated with Spanish sherry bodegas — in which the oldest casks in the Real expression date back decades. The tropical climate accelerates the angel's share to punishing levels, meaning what remains in the barrel is concentrated and deeply developed. Ron Centenario Real sits at the pinnacle of their range, yet it arrives without fanfare: no limited-edition numbering, no auction hype. It's a rum for people who understand that the most interesting things often happen underground, in the dark, over time. In an age of flashy single-cask releases, Real is a quiet argument for the beauty of blending, patience, and invisible craft.

Cocktail — The Root of Things — [object Object]

Pair with: The rum's layered darkness — coffee, leather, dried fruit — finds a natural counterpart in short ribs braised in a simplified mole sauce built on dried chilies, Mexican chocolate, and toasted sesame. The meat's unctuous richness mirrors the rum's velvety texture, while the mole's bittersweet complexity echoes the toffee and cocoa notes. Serve with a side of black beans and charred corn tortillas to keep things grounded.

Awards: International Wine & Spirit Competition — Gold (2019), San Francisco World Spirits Competition — Double Gold, International Spirits Challenge — Gold

Red Wine G.D. Vajra Barbera d'Alba DOC 2022

The Vaira family has farmed vineyards in the Barolo commune of Vergne since the 1970s, and their Barbera — grown on sandy-calcareous soils at elevation — consistently overdelivers for its modest price.

Pair with: Hand-rolled tajarin egg noodles tossed with browned butter and crispy sage leaves — a Piedmontese classic where the Barbera's acidity cuts through the butter while the cherry fruit complements the pasta's egg richness.

White Wine Donnafugata Lighea Zibibbo Sicilia DOC 2023

The Rallo family's Donnafugata estate has championed Sicily's native grape varieties since 1983, vinifying their Zibibbo from wind-swept vineyards on the volcanic island of Pantelleria and mainland Contessa Entellina.

Pair with: Tender grilled calamari dressed with fresh lemon juice, briny capers, and a drizzle of Sicilian extra-virgin olive oil — the wine's saline minerality and citrus notes create a seamless coastal pairing.

Train Your Nose: Today's Aroma Spotlight

This issue's aroma theme centers on the raw materials asserting themselves — grain sweetness in bourbon, malt in Scotch and Irish, cooked agave in tequila, sugarcane in clairin, and fruit-forward varietal character in the wines. Train your nose to find the ingredient beneath the process.

Each bottle below maps to aromas you can isolate with your kit before your next pour — then see if you catch them in the glass.

Today's Kit Reference

Explore the School of Wine and Spirits

Developing your ability to detect these root aromas — corn, malt, agave, sugarcane, cherry, melon — is exactly what our aroma training kits are designed to accelerate. Our Aroma Masterclass Kits are designed to teach it to you, one aroma at a time.

Our books on Amazon go deeper into the science and history behind every sip — from America's Spirit, Scotland's Spirit, Ireland's Spirit, The Ultimate Northern Italian Wine Journey, The Tequila y Mezcal Revolution, Chablis, and Côte d'Or pocket guides.

Explore our Aroma Masterclass kits and books at schoolofwineandspirits.com

The root speaks first; the trained nose listens.

Until tomorrow's pour — cheers.